Collective vs Formations: which one fits your business?

Side-by-side comparison of Collective and Formations — fees, features, ease, support, and which one fits your business. Scored on the same rubric.

Short answer: Formations wins on our scorecard (8/10 vs 7.9/10).

Scored onCollectiveFormations
Right fit for small biz99
Ease of use88
Fees & pricing77
Customer support67
Features99
Monthly Subscription$349/mo—
Annual Subscription (Prepaid)$297/mo—
S-Corp ElectionIncludedIncluded
Tax PreparationIncluded—
Monthly Starting Price—$249 - $299
1120-S Tax Return—Included
1040 Personal Return—Included (1)

Collective in one paragraph

The premier choice for high-earning solopreneurs who want to automate their S-Corp tax strategy without hiring an expensive local firm.

Skip it if: Skip it if you have W-2 employees or your annual net profit is below $70,000.

Read the full Collective review

Formations in one paragraph

Formations is the premier 'back-office-in-a-box' for solo professionals who want to capture S-Corp tax savings without the administrative headache.

Skip it if: You are a multi-member LLC or earn less than $60,000 in annual profit.

Read the full Formations review

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, Collective or Formations?

On our five-axis scorecard, Formations scores higher (8/10 vs 7.9/10). Formations is the premier 'back-office-in-a-box' for solo professionals who want to capture S-Corp tax savings without the administrative headache.

Who should skip Collective?

Skip it if you have W-2 employees or your annual net profit is below $70,000.

Who should skip Formations?

You are a multi-member LLC or earn less than $60,000 in annual profit.

All accounting tax services reviews