When to Fire Your Contractor and Hire an Employee

Key Takeaways

• The financial break-even for in-sourcing usually occurs when a subcontracted function costs 1.5 times the salary of a full-time hire.
• You must verify worker status using the Department of Labor's six-factor economic reality test to avoid misclassification penalties.
• Bringing work in-house adds roughly 20 to 30 percent in hidden costs above base salary for taxes and equipment (plus benefits).
• Federal law requires you to verify every new hire's eligibility to work in the United States using Form I-9 within three days of their start date.

Say you run a landscaping business in Virginia spending $14,000 a month on a subcontracted hardscaping crew. They're reliable, but you're paying a 30% markup on their labor to their agency. You also have no control over their schedule. If you hire two full-time stonemasons at $55,000 each, your base payroll is $110,000 a year. Even after adding 25% for employer taxes, workers' comp, and benefits, your total cost is $137,500. By bringing that function in-house, you save $30,500 a year and gain total control over your project timelines.

Is it time to bring the function in-house?

The decision usually hits your desk when your revenue crosses the $1.5 million mark or when a specific outsourced line item exceeds $100,000 annually. At this stage, you aren't just buying a service. You're buying someone else's management overhead and profit margin. If you can manage the work yourself, that margin belongs in your pocket.

The Three Thresholds for In-Sourcing

• The Cost Threshold: Run the math on the 'fully loaded' cost. A $60,000 salary actually costs you about $75,000 once you account for the employer portion of FICA and unemployment taxes. You can estimate these obligations via the IRS website. If your current vendor bill is higher than that $75,000 figure, the move makes financial sense.
• The Quality Threshold: Subcontractors serve multiple masters. If your customer satisfaction scores are dropping because a vendor is slow to respond, the lost lifetime value of your clients might outweigh any savings from staying lean.
• The Legal Threshold: You cannot simply call a worker a contractor to save on taxes. The Department of Labor recently updated its guidance on independent contractor status, focusing on the economic dependence of the worker. If you plan to control how, when, and where the work is done, you must hire them as an employee.

The Management Tax You Forgot to Calculate

Owners often forget that bringing a function in-house trades a vendor invoice for a management burden. When you use a specialized agency for your marketing or accounting, they handle the training, the software licenses. And the back-bench if someone quits.

If you hire an internal marketing manager, you're now responsible for their professional development. You also have to buy their Adobe Suite subscription and their MacBook. These small costs add up. A good rule of thumb is to add $5,000 to $8,000 per head for 'tools and overhead' in the first year. If your business doesn't have the systems to train a new hire, you'll likely spend more in lost productivity than you save in vendor fees.

Can you actually manage this person?

Ask yourself if you know enough about the role to tell if they're doing a good job. A plumbing business owner knows how to spot a bad weld. That same owner might have no idea how to spot a bad Google Ads campaign. If you can't vet the quality of the work, you're better off paying a premium to an agency that provides built-in oversight. Only bring it in-house when you have the internal expertise to lead the new department.

Moving from 1099 to W-2

1. Audit the current spend. Look at your P&L for the last 12 months. Total up every invoice related to the function, including 'small' one-off fixes.
2. Draft a real job description. Don't just copy-paste from a competitor. List the specific outcomes you need to hit to justify the salary.
3. Check your insurance. Adding employees often triggers a jump in your General Liability or Professional Liability premiums. Call your broker before you sign an offer letter.
4. Set up payroll. If you already use Mercury or Bluevine, check their integrations with payroll providers like Gusto or QuickBooks.

Do you have enough consistent work to keep this person busy for 40 hours a week, every week, for the next year? If the answer is 'usually,' stick with the contractor for six more months.

Related free tool

Break-Even Calculator — Find the number of customers you need to stop losing money. Free, no signup to start.

---

📋 Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, financial, or professional advice. Laws and regulations change frequently, and the information presented may not reflect the most current legal developments. Always consult with a qualified professional (CPA, attorney, financial advisor) before making business decisions based on this content. MyBizNerd may receive compensation through affiliate links, but this never influences our recommendations.

---